Weak Aspects of Shakoor Zahid's Research Book "Mujjati Arwah-a- Talab" (A Critical Review)

Abstract

This article delves into a research book that focuses on the personality and art of Karim Dashti, examining Shakoor Zahid's MPhil thesis, which was subsequently published as a book. The critical analysis aims to uncover the book's shortcomings, shed light on the researcher's minor errors and omissions, and discuss the research methodology employed. Within this critical commentary, an in-depth exploration of the research methodology is presented. It highlights instances where the researcher may have been somewhat negligent in adhering to research standards and essentials. It is essential to emphasize that the objective of this research paper is not to discredit the entire book; rather, it seeks to identify and critique specific weaknesses. Throughout the book, there are notable areas where the researcher effectively employs sound research methods, and these commendable aspects should not be overlooked.