A Critical Review of Zubair Ali Zai's Objections on the Sahabah's Customary Ahadith Regarding the Place of Clasping Hands in Prayer

Abstract

This scholarly article delves into the foundational sources of guidance in Islam, the Qur'an and the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), emphasizing their integral role in providing comprehensive guidance for worldly and hereafter success. The Prophet's esteemed position as the "Teacher of the Book and Wisdom" during his blessed life prompted the Companions to seek his guidance on various matters. The actions of the Prophet (PBUH), validated by the Qur'an, were considered exemplary and thus deserving of emulation. While some traditions (hadiths) have been deemed weak by Muhadditheen, these scholars have clarified that weakness in authentication does not necessarily render them impractical. Despite religious prejudices suggesting otherwise, it is established that the routine actions of the Prophet were embraced by the Companions, followers, and Muhadditheen. The article addresses objections raised by contemporary scholar Hafiz Zubair Ali Zai regarding the hadiths related to the Place of Binding Hands in Prayer, offering a comprehensive and scholarly response to these objections. Through this analysis, the article contributes to the ongoing discourse surrounding the emulation of the Prophet's actions and the reliability of hadiths in guiding the practices of Muslims.